Autor:
Donald D. Trunkey, MD
Professor of Surgery and Past
Chairman
Department of Surgery at Oregon
Health & Science University in
Portland Oregon, USA. Dr. Trunkey
has published 167 peer-reviewed
journal articles, 196 chapters, and
24 books. Dr. Trunkey served in
Desert Storm in 1991, and has a
number of Honorary Fellowships,
including The Royal College of
Surgeons of England, Royal College
of Surgeons of Ireland, College of
Surgeons of South Africa, The Royal
College of Surgeons of Edinburgh,
Royal Australian College of
Surgeons, The Royal College of
Surgeons of Glasgow, Philippine
Society for the Surgery of Trauma,
and The Philadelphia Academy of
Surgery.
USA |
Four United States' presidents have been
assassinated during their terms of office:
Lincoln, Garfield, McKinley and Kennedy. The
surgical care provided to these assassinated
presidents was excellent in the case of
Lincoln and Kennedy. However, Garfield and
McKinley received marginal care, and a
strong argument can be made that their
surgery actually contributed to their
demise.
|
Lincoln Portrait |
Lincoln was shot on April 14, 1865 by John
Wilkes Booth, an actor from Maryland, who
was very anti-union. This was a conspiracy
that also involved attempts on the life of
the Vice-President and Secretary of State
Seward. The first person to reach Lincoln
after he'd been shot was a 24-year-old Army
surgeon, Dr. Charles Augustus Leale. His
care was truly remarkable and was very
similar to current ATLS guidelines.
The wound was obviously a fatal wound, and
the President lived for an additional 9
hours and 52 minutes. His assassin was also
killed by Boston Corbett two weeks later.
Eight of the conspirators went to military
trials, and four were sentenced to death,
which was carried out on the 7th
of July 1865.
Unfortunately, Lincoln and the remaining
three presidents who were assassinated had
poor autopsies that were either incomplete
or failed in getting all of the information
necessary to dispute conspiracy theories.
|
Garfield Portrait |
Garfield was shot on the 2nd of
July 1881 in a railroad station waiting to
start the July 4th holidays. One
of the wounds grazed his right arm; the
other entered the right side of his back
near the first lumbar vertebra. The wound
was continuously probed by many ungloved
surgeons' fingers, and the President
gradually developed malnutrition, sepsis,
and died on the 19th of September
1881. The autopsy showed that he had a fatal
hemorrhage from the splenic artery, probably
caused by the bullet, but possibly also by
either a finger or one of the multiple
probes that was inserted into his wound.
|
McKinley
Portrait |
The period of time between Garfield and
McKinley was marked by multiple
assassinations in Europe. Anarchists killed
the President of France, the Empress of
Austria and the King of Italy. During the
investigation of the king's death, a list of
six individuals was found, and William
McKinley was number five.
McKinley was shot on September 6, 1901 at
the Pan American Exposition in the Temple of
Music by an anarchist – Leon Csolgosz. He
was operated on by an obstetrician, who was
not familiar with management of either
gunshot wounds nor surgery in the upper
abdomen. McKinley lingered for almost a
week, but died of peritonitis on the 14th
of September at 2:00 am. At autopsy, the
bullet was never found, and the autopsy was
halted by President McKinley's wife.
Kennedy was assassinated on the 22nd
of November 1963 by Lee Harvey Oswald.
Kennedy was immediately taken to Parkland
Hospital, but died 30 minutes after arrival.
He was agonal when he arrived at the
emergency room. Trauma surgeons were
present, and his care was excellent. The
fatal wound involved the entire right
hemisphere of his brain.
Like President Lincoln, Kennedy's assassin
was killed one day later. There are some
remarkable similarities and coincidences
associated with the Lincoln/Kennedy
assassinations. Both were shot in the back
of the head on a Friday, seated with their
wives. Their associates were injured. Both
had partial autopsies, and both presidents
were rocking chair enthusiasts. Both
presidents' assassins were shot, and both
were succeeded by vice-presidents named
Johnson. There are almost 200 similarities
between Kennedy and Lincoln. I believe they
were simply coincidences.
The lessons learned from these four
assassinations include:
1. Single surgeon/captain of the
ship
2. Appropriate use of consultants
3. Non committee medicine
4. Appropriate nursing care
5. Expert forensic pathology
6. Complete autopsy
|